We've now had four different mission threads, each with multiple places to "fish" that can drop items to sell from our inventory.
With that in mind, and with so many to keep track of, we thought it would be worth collecting them all together in one post and sorting them by reward type... so here we go!
Each is listed by name, reward amount and location found.
Stick Bug - 1 Horseshoe - Rotting Log
Black Scorpion - 1 Horseshoe - Musty Shack
Cup and Ball - 1 Horseshoe - Whack a Varmint
Solid Gold Ticket - 1 Horseshoe - Bottle Toss
Snapped Branches - 1 Horseshoe - Foothill Path
Groaning Reply - 1 Horseshoe - Thick Forest
Crooked Deals - 1 Horseshoe - Leadership Scene
Unpaid Bill - 1 Horseshoe - Family Scene
Native Feast - 1 Horseshoe - Longhouse
Floating Embers - 1 Horseshoe - Stirring of Ashes
Iridescent Dragonfly - 2 Horseshoes - Vibrant Meadow
Perfect Shooter Marble - 2 Horseshoes - Milk Can Toss
Thrown Pinecones - 2 Horseshoes - Rocky Knoll
Shady Children - 2 Horseshoes - Education Scene
Vision Juice - 2 Horseshoes - Medicine Men
Golden Fleece - 3 Horseshoes - High Striker
Shimmering Domino - 5 Gold Dust - Bottle Toss
Tarantula - 10 Gold Dust - Musty Shack
Leafy Bed - 10 Gold Dust - Thick Forest
Empty Belly - 10 Gold Dust - Family Scene
Fiery Coals - 10 Gold Dust - Stirring of Ashes
Stuffed Bicep - 15 Gold Dust - High Striker
Wooden yo yo - 1'500 Coins - Whack a Varmint
Grasshopper - 2'000 coins - Rotting Log
Hair Snag - 2'000 Coins - Foothill Path
No Direction - 2'000 coins - Leadership Scene
Ancient Story - 2'000 coins, Longhouse
Moth - 3'000 coins - Musty Shack
Silver Bottle - 3'000 coins - Bottle Toss
Tree Scratches - 3'000 Coins - Thick Forest
Giftless Tree - 3'000 coins - Family Scene
Hot Log - 3'000 coins - Stirring of Ashes
Jack Plushie - 3'500 coins - High Striker
Big Bumblebee - 4'000 coins - Vibrant Meadow
Jacobs Ladder - 4'000 Coins - Milk Can Toss
Huge Footprint - 4'000 Coins - Rocky Knoll
Outdated Books - 4'000 coins - Education Scene
Health Potion - 4'000 coins - Medicine Men
Stuffed Mole - 5'000 Coins - Whack a Varmint
Centipede - 15'000 coins - Rotting Log
Big Toenail - 15'000 Coins - Foothill Path
Cooked Books - 15'000 coins - Leadership Scene
Wise Men - 15'000 coins - Longhouse
Praying Mantis - 750 XP - Vibrant Meadow
Pack of Jacks - 750XP - Milk Can Toss
Peering Figure - 750 XP - Rocky Knoll
Dunce Cap - 750XP - Education Scene
Anti Agining Serum - 750 XP - Medicine Men